Rescue & Recovery at 20: Phil Alvarez, Suffolk PD

Rescue & Recovery at 20: Phil Alvarez, Suffolk PD

  • May 25, 2022
Four men stand in front of a mustard-colored curtain
Faye Murman, Collection 9/11 Memorial Museum

From left: Phil Alvarez; his brother Luis, a first responder who died from 9/11-related health issues; Jon Feal, a retired construction worker who survived 9/11 and became an advocate for first responders; the writer and comedian Jon Stewart, a long-time advocate for first responder health benefits. 

Phil Alvarez was a Suffolk County Police detective on 9/11. His brother Luis, an NYPD detective, spent months at Ground Zero and ultimately died in 2019 from a related illness. The following Q&A with Alvarez is part of our ongoing series highlighting the stories of those most closely involved with the rescue and recovery efforts, which formally came to an end 20 years ago this coming Monday. 

Ahead of our May 30th commemoration, Alvarez will speak as a panelist at our special public program, "Advocacy and Activism," alongside fellow first responder Rob Serra and film director Bridget Gormley, whose firefighter father also succumbed to 9/11-related illness.

Where were you on 9/11? 
I was a Suffolk County Police Detective, living on Long Island, watching the terror unfold on television.  
 
What role did you and/or your family member play in the rescue, recovery, and relief efforts? 
My brother, NYPD Detective Luis (Lou) Alvarez, and his unit were mobilized to Ground Zero for search, rescue, and recovery. Many including Lou were there for three months or more.  

A man is seated at a table while two others stand to his left and right. Behind him are several rows of clapping people, in front of a row with the symbol of Congress.

Applause after Luis Alvarez (center, seated) and Jon Stewart testify before Congress in support of permanent authorization of the VCF. Phil Alvarez stands in the audience, in light blue shirt. 

How was your brother impacted by his time at Ground Zero?  
My brother, Luis, knew shortly after arriving at Ground Zero that the rescue mission would quickly become one of recovery. He felt, out of honor and respect, that families who lost loved ones were owed their remains, so that they could have closure. He felt that was paramount and took it as a personal quest. 

Lou was diagnosed in 2016 with colorectal cancer that had metastasized to his liver. His cancer was certified by the World Trade Center Health Program as stemming from exposure to the toxins at Ground Zero. This began a new mission for my brother: find all those that had been there with him and make sure they had access to health coverage and compensation. My brother became a 9/11 victim advocate and the face of the fight for the permanent authorization of the September 11th Victim Compensation Fund - which culminated in the “Never Forget the Heroes: James Zadroga, Ray Pfeifer, and Luis Alvarez Permanent Authorization of the September 11th Victim Compensation Fund Act.” It was signed into law [in July 2019] exactly one month after he passed, funding the VCF through the year 2090. This came weeks after he testified before Congress alongside many other advocates including comedian/activist [and Museum board member] Jon Stewart for the permanent authorization bill. 

What does May 30th mean to you?
May 30th reminds me of all the brave souls that responded to Ground Zero to help battle the absolute destruction and terror in New York City. They responded so that a country that had been brought to its knees by terrorists could show the world that we could work together without thoughts of race, color, politics, or religion and help each other.  May 30th is also a time for me to remember and honor all the heroes we have lost due to illnesses contracted from the toxins at Ground Zero. Besides the initial 23 NYPD heroes who died when the towers fell, my brother was the 222nd to die from his time spent at Ground Zero. 

Why is it important for you to share your story - and the stories of others - with the generation now growing up with no memory of September 11th?  
It is important for those with no memory of September 11th to hear the individual stories about how a beautiful day in NYC, blue skies without a cloud to be seen, became one of the darkest days in the history of the world and it changed how we live. But it also is important to tell how a nation came together to survive this dark day.  

Anything else you’d like to add?
My thoughts and prayers are with all those who suffered and are still suffering from September 11th, 2001. May God bless us all! 

Compiled by Caitlyn Best, Government and Community Affairs Coordinator

See Also:
CNN

NYPD Officer Follows in Footsteps of Father Killed on 9/11

NYPD Officer Follows in Footsteps of Father Killed on 9/11

NYPD member Joseph Vigiano’s portrait and profile are seen on the Museum’s Memorial Guide.
Joseph Vigiano's placement on the 9/11 Memorial. His name is next to his brother, John T. Vigiano II, who was also killed responding to 9/11.

He was just 8 years old when his father and uncle both died in the line of duty on 9/11. Now, 23-year-old Joseph Vigiano Jr. has followed in his father’s footsteps, becoming an NYPD officer.

A former Marine, Vigiano was one of 600 recruits recently sworn in at a police academy in Queens, according to the New York Daily News.

"I’ve been waiting for this all my life," Vigiano told the Daily News. "As a kid I always wanted to be a police officer or in the military and now I get to do both."

His father, NYPD Detective Joseph Vigiano, was killed attempting to rescue those trapped in the World Trade Center. His uncle, John Vigiano Jr., was a third-generation FDNY firefighter and was also killed responding to the towers.

"My father truly did love his job and if I could just experience a fraction of that, it’ll be all worth it," Vigiano told reporters.

Watch the animated short by StoryCorps of John Vigiano Sr., a retired FDNY firefighter, as he reminisces about his sons John Vigiano Jr. and Joseph Vigiano.

By 9/11 Memorial Staff

The Lens: Capturing Life and Events at the 9/11 Memorial and Museum

The Lens: Capturing Life and Events at the 9/11 Memorial and Museum

An NYPD officer places a blue rose at a name on the 9/11 Memorial during National Police Week.
NYPD officer places at blue rose at the 9/11 Memorial in honor of National Police week. Photo by Jin Lee.

The Lens: Capturing Life and Events at the 9/11 Memorial and Museum is a photography series devoted to documenting moments big and small that unfold at the 9/11 Memorial and Museum.

The View: In honor of National Police Week, NYPD and PAPD officers placed blue roses in the names of their fallen comrades at the 9/11 Memorial on Friday, May 13. On 9/11, 23 NYPD officers and 37 PAPD officers were killed.  By 9/11 Memorial Staff

NYPD Headquarters Displays Portraits of 9/11 Heroes

NYPD Headquarters Displays Portraits of 9/11 Heroes

Stephen Gardner, Anthony Bonano and former NYPD Commissioner William Bratton stand next to a painting of NYPD Deputy Chief Steve Bonano.
Left to right, Stephen Gardner, Anthony Bonano and NYPD Commissioner William Bratton stand next to a painting of NYPD Deputy Chief Steve Bonano. Photo by NYPD

NYPD Commissioner William Bratton joined family members of 9/11 first responders at a luncheon on Feb. 1 to commemorate the extension of the Zadroga Act, according to the New York Daily News.

One of the family members in attendance was Jillian Suarez, daughter of Officer Ramon Suarez, who is depicted in a portrait helping a survivor on 9/11 shortly before he was killed. Jillian Suarez told the Daily News that the portrait of her father touched her heart, "to see how they did the painting, from his chin to every part of his body and the way they captured every moment, including the background."

The portraits were previously exhibited in the Senate Rotunda in Washington D.C. and are now on display inside NYPD Headquarters at 1 Police Plaza.

By Christine Murphy, 9/11 Memorial Administration/Researcher

Holiday Ornament Recovered at Ground Zero Donated to Museum

Holiday Ornament Recovered at Ground Zero Donated to Museum

An ornament recovered at Ground Zero is displayed on a black surface. The ornament depicts the Twin Towers on a starry night.
Ornament recovered by Steve Steo at ground zero. Collection of 9/11 Memorial Museum, Gift of Detective Steve A. Steo (Ret.) in memory of Joseph Vigiano

Steve Steo, an NYPD Detective with the 75th Precinct in Brooklyn, New York, reported to ground zero on Sept. 12, 2001 to aid in the search and rescue of survivors after the 9/11 attacks. Recently, the 9/11 Memorial Museum acquired an artifact that speaks to Steo’s time at ground zero and calls to memory the strange somberness of the holiday season that year.

Steo’s efforts during the first days of the response were personally driven. His good friend, Joseph Vigiano, a detective with NYPD Emergency Services Squad 2, was among the first responders reported missing. Vigiano’s older brother, FDNY Firefighter John Vigiano was also reported missing.

After both brothers were confirmed dead, Steo never relented in his effort to locate them during his six-month tenure on recovery detail.

On the evening of Sept. 18, Steo rappelled into a deep void in hopes of locating his friends. As he worked his way out of the fallen steel, a glittering object caught his eye. This turned out to be a relatively intact souvenir Christmas ornament which was likely once sold in the gift shop at the World Trade Center’s South Tower Observatory.

The ornament depicts a gilded World Trade Center complex set against a gold, star-flecked, deep blue sky, with the Statue of Liberty and Hudson River in the foreground. The reverse side is punctuated by bold, red, letters that read, “Peace on Earth.”

Many years later, Steo met with the 9/11 Memorial Museum’s Associate Curator Alexandra Drakakis and presented the ornament to the museum in memory of his fallen friend, Joseph Vigiano.

By Jenny Pachucki, 9/11 Memorial Content Strategist

9/11 Memorial Honors Slain NYPD Officer Randolph Holder

9/11 Memorial Honors Slain NYPD Officer Randolph Holder

9/11 Memorial President Joe Daniels addresses dozens of NYPD officers beside a reflecting pool on Memorial plaza.
9/11 Memorial President Joe Daniels addressing a line of officers. Photo: Jin Lee.

The 9/11 Memorial held a tribute Thursday to honor Randolph Holder, a 33-year-old New York City police officer who was fatally shot in the line of duty in an East Harlem neighborhood. Dozens of officers from the New York City Police Department and Port Authority Police Department gathered at the South Pool of the 9/11 Memorial, where the names of the 23 NYPD members who were killed on 9/11 are etched in the bronze parapets.

Following a moment of silence, attending officers and 9/11 Memorial staff placed white and yellow flowers on the names.

“We at the 9/11 Memorial and Museum will always share a heartfelt connection with the NYPD and PAPD, and it’s an honor to do our part in remembering their service,” 9/11 Memorial President Joe Daniels said. “This memorial reminds us that officers came here on 9/11 and gave their lives to save others. But it’s important to also remember that brave men and women like officer Holder continue to get up every single day and put their lives on the line for the people of New York.”

Holder, who was killed Tuesday, was inspired to join the NYPD by his father and grandfather, who both served as police officers in Guyana, according to the New York Times

This was the second tribute held for a fallen officer at the 9/11 Memorial. In 2014, officers Wenjian Liu and Rafael Ramos were honored following an ambush that took the lives of both men.

By Kaylee Skaar, 9/11 Memorial Communications Manager

The Lens: Capturing Life and Events at the 9/11 Memorial and Museum

The Lens: Capturing Life and Events at the 9/11 Memorial and Museum

A man and a young boy make an etching of a loved one’s name inscribed on the Memorial.
Family members make an etching of a loved one's name inscribed on the memorial. Photo: Monica Graff.

The Lens: Capturing Life and Events at the 9/11 Memorial and Museum is a photography series devoted to documenting moments big and small that unfold at the 9/11 Memorial and Museum.

The View: Family members create an etching of an NYPD ESU responder’s name on the South Pool of the 9/11 Memorial on September 11, 2015. The 9/11 Memorial hosted the 14th anniversary commemoration ceremony for the families of the nearly 3,000 victims of the 9/11 attacks.  

 By 9/11 Memorial Staff

Museum Events Honor Rescuers, Recovery Workers

Museum Events Honor Rescuers, Recovery Workers

Two gloves belonging to NYPD officer David Brink are displayed at the Museum. The works “Thank You” have been written on both gloves in marker.
During the recovery efforts, the words “thank you” were written on the gloves of NYPD officer David Brink by an unknown well-wisher reminding him of the public’s appreciation. (Photo: Amy Dreher)

From May 28 through May 30, 2015, the 9/11 Memorial Museum will hold events to honor those who participated in rescue and recovery at the World Trade Center and Pentagon after September 11, 2001.

May 28, 2002 marked the date that construction workers cut down the “Last Column,” the final standing steel column of the World Trade Center. On May 30, 2002, the column was ceremonially removed from the site in a public event.

On Thursday, May 28, 2015 from 4 p.m. to 5 p.m., an expert panel, including a former NYPD detective who responded on 9/11 and a pulmonary specialist, will explore illnesses linked to WTC exposure and efforts to treat and compensate those affected. The event is free with Museum admission, but space is limited. Tickets can be reserved here.

For rescue and recovery workers, the Museum will extend its hours on May 28 for a special evening of tribute and remembrance in Foundation Hall. On May 30, StoryCorps, the national oral history initiative, is hosting a recording day at the Museum, during which rescue and recovery workers can discuss their experiences at the attack sites following 9/11. Recording times must be scheduled in advance, and space is limited. For more information, contact Anthony Gardner.

Rescue and recovery workers are welcome to visit the Museum from May 28 through May 30 with complimentary admission for two guests. Registration is required for complimentary admission.

More information is available here.

By 9/11 Memorial Staff

Memorial Honors Slain NYPD Officer Brian Moore

Memorial Honors Slain NYPD Officer Brian Moore

NYPD officers place flowers on the inscribed names of officers who died on 9/11.
NYPD officers place flowers on the names of those officers who died on 9/11. (Photo: Jin Lee)

The 9/11 Memorial honored slain NYPD Officer Brian Moore in a ceremony held Tuesday afternoon on the Memorial plaza.

Given the Memorial’s deep connection with first responders and our focus on recognizing the sacrifices they make to protect citizens, Memorial staff joined members of the NYPD and PAPD, gathering at the NYPD section on the south side of the South Pool.

After a short speech from 9/11 Memorial President Joe Daniels, staff members and first responders placed flowers on the section of the memorial where the names of NYPD officers who died on 9/11 are located.

By Jordan Friedman, 9/11 Memorial Research and Digital Projects Associate

Texas Girl Sends NYPD Officers 200 Thank You Cards

Texas Girl Sends NYPD Officers 200 Thank You Cards

About a dozen NYPD officers in formal uniforms stand beside a reflecting pool at the 9/11 Memorial on the 10th anniversary of the 9/11 attacks.
NYPD officers at the 10th anniversary of 9/11 on the memorial plaza. (Photo: Amy Dreher)

Just as the 9/11 Memorial Museum honors the courageous efforts of the first responders to the terrorist attacks, a 10-year-old girl from Texas has expressed her appreciation for NYPD officers by sending them 200 handmade thank you cards, the New York Daily News reports.

Savannah Solis sent the cards following the Dec. 20, 2014 murders of NYPD Officers Wenjian Liu and Rafael Ramos.

“I just want to say thank you for taking care of us every day,” Savannah wrote in one of the cards. “You are my hero and you’re brave too. Keep watching out for us.”

Fourth-grader Savannah Solis arrived in New York on Sunday, where she will visit the 41st and 84th Precinct stationhouses.

You can read about her visit to New York in the Daily News.

By Jordan Friedman, 9/11 Memorial Research and Digital Projects Associate

Subscribe to NYPD